What is the ceiling for Philly? Three Questions on the Union

In their second year in MLS, the Philadelphia Union surprised the league by combining unbreakable defense with timely scoring.  Philly was in the top three of the East most of the season before slipping a bit at the end of the year and bowing out of the playoffs to eventual champ Houston.  Regardless, the year has to be seen as an unquestionable success, as the team secured a lucrative shirt sponsorship deal, packed its new soccer stadium, and showed that it could compete long-term in MLS.

So, with the calendar turned to 2012, where does this team stand in the offseason?  Has it improved or what does it need to do to improve?  The Philadelphia Union are up next in our “Three Questions” series:

1. What will you do, Freddy Adu?

Freddy Adu joined his fellow U.S. national team hopefuls by going overseas to train with a foreign club team to improve his skills and get additional playing time.  However, unlike some of his teammates, it looks like the short training spell could turn into something longer.  Reports from Spain suggest that struggling Rayo Vallecano may be impressed enough with his training to extend an offer to the forward for the rest of the season.

Adu’s impact on the Union last season was less than expected (or at least less than the optimists expected) but two factors were at play.  First, he played less than half a season and was adjusting back to MLS after spending time in some vastly different European leagues.  Second, he was added as “instant offense”, an impact player off the bench where a full year in MLS might see him starting more often.  Honestly, his departure would not sink the Union, but it would leave them needing to find another veteran scorer.  His leaving or staying may dictate where Philly turns the rest of their offseason attention.

2. Have the offseason signings addressed their needs?

As soon as the book closed on the 2011 season, the Union were opening their check book (or whatever the 2012 equivalent is).  They offloaded Justin Mapp and some pricey depth players and addressed some glaring needs: forward (Josue Martinez), left back (Porfirio Lopez), and central midfielder (Gabriel Gomez).  In addition, they added another hometown signing in Jimmy McLaughlin who joins Zach Pfeffer as the team’s second “local” youngster.  While the team still has some positions it can beef up (especially if #1 comes true) the front office did what they did last offseason, struck early to address their needs and filled in where necessary.  Soon enough we’ll see if this strategy works again.

3.  What is Sebastien Le Toux role on this team?

In their inaugural season, the French-American was a scoring machine for the Union, notching 14 goals and being named to the MLS All Star team.  Last season, his scoring decreased but he played more as a creator, setting up his forwards to score their own goals.  Despite his scoring dropping, the team’s record improved.  So is Le Toux a scorer or a creator?  A Van Persie or a Fabregas?  How Nowak uses his going forward will give this team a definite identity going into a season where they will no longer be considered underdogs, but potential favorites in the East.

2 Responses to What is the ceiling for Philly? Three Questions on the Union

  1. Earl Reed says:

    This is a pivotal year for Nowak in my opinion. Some have mentioned the Union as a contender for MLS Cup. From my perspective, Coach Nowak really needs to figure out his “first team” and stick with it. His defense and goalkeeper were relatively settled last season barring injury or punishment, however that was the area of the squad with the least depth.

    But the part that is most pivotal lies in the group of youngsters who have patiently waited for their time to step up. Four players in particular are on my mind: Danny Mwanga (the #1 pick in the 2010 SuperDraft), Amobi Okugo, Jack McInerney, and Roger Torres. For one thing, it’s unclear that Torres will return, which would be a shame if he didn’t because he has begun to blossom. But with the acquisitions of Josue Martinez and Gabriel Gomez, the first three players now are even more challenged for time with the first team. As the GenAdidas guys come out of the program, their salaries become burdensome if they aren’t contributing.

    And finally, you mention Adu. He completed his 2011 campaign as a luxury player, making an engorged salary without much return on investment (his salary ranks around #10 in the league). In my mind if the Union are not able to re-up the loan of Torres, Adu must develop into a key player for this team. And if Nowak isn’t convinced of that, he should be helping Adu look for apartments in Madrid.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *